Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 7)

I’ve continued to sleep extremely well. I’m sure there’s something to this. I’m almost sure it’s because of the one-legged standing.

Here are some technical details. I usually do four bouts of one-legged standing, two in the morning and two later. During each bout I stand on one leg, pulling my other leg up behind me. Sometimes I touch something to balance myself. Usually I watch or read something at the same time. Each bout lasts until it’s hard to continue — until it becomes slightly painful. At first the bouts lasted about two minutes, now they last about four minutes. I enjoy it more when I time it with a stopwatch.

I haven’t yet systematically varied the number of bouts but I suspect one is too few to get the full effect and four is plenty. I’m still trying different ways of arranging them throughout the day. Doing all four at once is too tiring — it takes too long to recover. Maybe it’s best to do two whenever’s convenient during the day and then do two more in the evening when it’s okay to be tired.

Directory.

Why Did I Sleep So Well? directory

  1. Initial observation, 9 possible causes
  2. Another possible cause: standing on one foot
  3. Sleep almost great, narrowing possible causes to two.
  4. Sleep great again, narrowing possible causes to two
  5. Sleep great again after only standing on one foot
  6. Someone else gets similar results
  7. Technical details
  8. How long I stand
  9. Eerie coincidence
  10. Patterns of discovery
  11. Comparison to other sorts of exercise
  12. What’s a good dose?
  13. How much I’ve been standing Comparison with conventional exercise.
  14. Two more people get similar results
  15. How long I stand (continued)
  16. Replication details
  17. The amount of time needed stops increasing

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 6)

On the SLD forums Heidi 555 posted this:

I’ve been standing on one foot on an inexpensive balance board or inflatable balance disc. . . . I’ve been using the balance board while doing dishes and brushing my teeth. . . .

I feel good immediately afterwards. I feel slightly better physically and emotionally. . . . I’m use to feeling better after I exercise, but typically it takes more intensive sustained exercise to get this effect.

I sleep well 60-70% of the time. . . . For the past 3 days that I’ve done the one-footed standing I’ve had excellent sleep. Last night it was especially surprising because I went to bed emotionally distraught and stayed up slightly later than I intended.

Directory.

The Quantified Self Meetup Group

Gary Wolf, a writer for Wired, and Kevin Kelly, one of the founders of Wired, have formed a San Francisco Bay Area Meetup group called The Quantified Self.

This is a monthly show and tell for people taking advantage of various kinds of personal tracking – geotracking, life-logging, DNA sequencing, etc. – to gain more knowledge about themselves. Come whare what you are doing, and learn from others. Topics include, but are not limited to:

  • Chemical Body
  • Load Counts
  • Personal Genome Sequencing
  • Lifelogging
  • Self Experimentation
  • Risks/Legal Rights/DutiesBehavior monitoring
  • Location tracking
  • Non-invasive Probes
  • Digitizing Body Info
  • Sharing Health Records
  • Psychological Self-Assesments
  • Medical Self-Diagnostics

The first meeting, which I will eagerly attend, will be on September 10 (Wed) evening in Pacifica. Sign up for details.

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 5)

I have been sleeping much better than usual. Sharp easy-to-notice improvement. After the first time this happened I made a list of 9 possible reasons (lifestyle changes that might have been responsible). I later added one I’d overlooked: standing on one foot to exhaustion a few times.

Yesterday I stood on one foot to exhaustion four times, twice in the morning and twice in the evening. It took about three minutes each time (12 minutes total). Didn’t make any of the nine other candidate changes. And I slept much better than usual. So it is beginning to look like just that one factor is responsible. The one I almost forgot but also the one that seemed most plausible after i remembered it.

Directory.

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 4)

I repeated the two things that remained on my list as possibilities for why I slept so well a few nights ago: 1. Looked at my face in a mirror a half-hour earlier than usual with a better sound source. 2. Stood on one foot until exhaustion (6 times). Lo and behold, I slept great. Now I’m pretty sure one of these two, or their combination, is responsible.

An unexpected twist is that I only slept 5 hours. Usually I’d still feel tired after that little sleep. But I feel like I slept 7 or 8.

I suspect the standing, not the faces, is the cause. Which would be ironic. Of the treatments I’ve studied by self-experimentation and found helpful, standing 9 or 10 hours, which greatly improved my sleep, was the most difficult. I loved what it did to my sleep. I still remember how wonderful it felt to be so well-rested the next morning. Even so I stopped doing it. As an experimental treatment, it was hard to measure how long I stood. As a lifestyle change, it was really hard to arrange so much standing. Whereas standing on one foot to exhaustion six times might be the easiest effective treatment I’ve studied (if it’s effective). Easy to measure, nothing to buy, no logistical problems.

I may try to repeat the earlier observation a few more times — as a kind of gift to myself — but now the main thing I want to do is separate the effects of the two factors, i.e., test one without the other.

Directory.

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 3)

Yesterday I did two of the 10 or so possible things that might have caused me to sleep really well recently: (a) looked at my face in a mirror earlier than usual with voices behind the mirror (Factor A) and (b) stood on one foot until exhaustion (twice) (Factor B). And last night I slept better than usual — not quite as great as the first time but still really well. This seems to narrow down the possibilities to:

  • Factor A only
  • Factor B only
  • Factor A and Factor B

I have doubts about Factor A. After I figured out that seeing faces in the morning improved my mood, I tried for months to find the right “dose” (right time, right length) to improve my sleep. I didn’t find it. Whereas Factor B is merely a new version of something that has improved my sleep countless times, so much that I’ve noticed its effects when not looking for them. The effect might have been less clear last night than the first time because I only stood on one foot to exhaustion twice. The first time — I wasn’t paying attention, of course — I think I did it three or four times.

So today I did it six times. It was curiously exhausting. After I felt recovered (about an hour later), the rest of the day I felt really good, cheerful and energetic — better than after yoga. That doesn’t make a lot of sense. If I do something that makes me sleep better, shouldn’t it make me more tired?

Directory.

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well? (part 2)

A few days ago (Tuesday night) I slept unusually well, presumably because Tuesday day had been unusual in some way. I made a list of nine possible reasons.

Today I realized I’d forgotten something: 10. Stood on one foot more than usual. To pass the time while looking at my face in the mirror I had stood on one foot while stretching the other leg, pulling my foot up behind me. I was curious how long I could do this so I did a few trials with each leg where I did it until it became too painful. I lasted about 2 minutes on one leg and 2.5 minutes on the other.

This might seem trivial — and I forgot about it. But standing on one foot continuously for a relatively long time surely stressed my leg muscles much more than usual. Previous research convinced me that standing many hours improves sleep. Maybe this “extreme standing” produces the same hormonal effects in a few minutes as normal standing does in ten hours. That would be wonderful!

Directory.

Science in Action: Why Did I Sleep So Well?

Last night I slept extremely well. I slept about eight hours and woke up feeling really good. In the past I’ve slept this well only after being on my feet nine or ten hours. Yesterday I was on my feet maybe four hours. I usually sleep well but this was a distinct improvement.

What caused it? Yesterday had many unusual features (like most days), but I did deliberately vary one thing:

1. I looked at faces (actually, my face in a mirror) earlier than usual. Usually I start around 7:40 am; yesterday I started about 7:10 am. (Background: I discovered that seeing faces in the morning improves my mood the next day. For example, seeing faces Monday morning improves my mood on Tuesday. And makes my mood worse Monday night. Details here.) I’ve done this before — watched the faces earlier than usual — and hadn’t noticed anything unusual. Yesterday may have been different, however, because three days ago I changed something. I always listen to something (audiobook, a Google Talk, This American Life episode, etc.) while I look at my face in the mirror. Three days ago I moved the sound source directly behind the mirror.

This is my best guess why my sleep was better than usual. But yesterday was unusual in several other ways as well:

2. I went outside (in the shade) 30 minutes earlier than usual.

3. Usually wear contact lenses while sleeping but didn’t.

4. Usually wear a tooth guard while sleeping but didn’t.

5. Salmon for dinner, which isn’t unusual, but I had more than usual.

6. No aerobic exercise.

7. Did a lot of chores I’d put off. (Peace of mind?)

8. On the preceding days, the sound source was behind the mirror. In other words, it was the cumulative effect that produced better sleep.

9. The end of a cold.

Now I’ll do all sorts of things to test these possibilities.

There’s a saying No one believes a theory but the theorist; everyone believes an experiment but the experimenter. This illustrates why. The experimenter can see all sorts of confoundings and special circumstances that others cannot.

Directory.

What Do Organizers Do?

At a cooking class, I met Ami DeAvilla, a professional organizer. It’s a profession so new — 15 years old? — that I was curious what sort of problems she works with. She told me some examples:

Example 1. A woman who was 4 years behind filing her taxes. She was collecting the letters from Franchise Tax Board and the IRS. There wasn’t that much money involved — she might even have had some money owed to her. Became overwhelming and daunting. As the years went on, doing her taxes became overwhelming. She had a “fear basket”: those letters went in it. I was able to come in & open the most recent of the letters. She did have all of the info. There was a lot of fear involved. Also she had gotten divorced. Emotion of having to handle financial stuff on her own. She contacted me because she knew she needed to file but couldn’t do it on her own. Her sister found me through the website of the National Association of Professional Organizers. We met twice/week for a few hours. We did 3 years together; she did the last one on her own. Total 15 hours [Ami’s current rate is $100/hour]. One 3-hour session was about her current relationship to money, which was as important as the taxes. Just as having a heart attack can lead you to improve your health habits because it indicates a greater problem.

Example 2. A woman who for 37 years had been in the same home. She needed to decide whether to stay there because her husband’s health was getting worse. It was a two- story house. Two sets of steps to climb because it was on a hill. Not possible for him to be mobile in and out of the house. He had severe back pain and had trouble getting up the stairs. It was her home. She didn’t want to leave. She was feeling overwhelmed with the decisions to be made. After she decided to move, there were decisions about their stuff. They were moving to a much smaller place. Moving from four-bedroom house to three-room apartment. Sorting through their entire life. Dividing belongings among all their children and grandchildren.

Example 3. A small business owner who had been in practice for over 20 years. His home-based office was a mess. People not billed. Papers all over the office. He works on site. He came to me because it was daunting to take care of tasks that needed to happen. He would hire someone to help in the office but they wouldn’t work there until it was cleaned up. They didn’t want to feel overwhelmed by the clutter. He wasn’t able to clean up his office. He was working a lot of hours, trying to balance personal life with business life. Now that he was taking some personal time, and not working all night, business things weren’t being taken care of.

Example 4. Published author, several books out. She was juggling four pressing projects and trying to start a website. Continuing on a book she was halfway into. Couldn’t make the writing work. I worked her with for 2 hrs to help her prioritize her time. Previously she was able to manage some of this better. When the website came along it became another project that kept the writing from happening. She’d been working on the book for a year or less; she was more than halfway through, and now falling behind the publisher’s deadline. She wanted a plan, plus physical organization of her workspace. We shifted the space a little bit to help her focus on writing. She was getting distracted too much.

Example 5. A woman called me because her house was not the way she wanted it. Three people had died and she had inherited their belongings. She felt overwhelmed in her own home. She’d lived there over 20 years. It was overwhelming to go through things and make decisions about what she wanted to keep. Stuff had gotten packed in quite a bit. We went through her house room by room and cleared stuff out. Started in the kitchen. Less emotional. Not much room left on the counters. We did 4 or 5 rooms, including office space. She had been a graphic designer.

You can reach Ami at amisolutions at mac dot com.